Gallipoli Gelibolu Symposium

Held at the Art Gallery of NSW, Friday 22 May 2015

by Stephanie Bailey.

Anyone who has spent more than five minutes in my company will be aware of my - let's call it what it is - obsession with military history, in particular Australia's involvement in the First World War.
Wine of victory, Will Dyson, 1918.

And so, with the 100 year anniversary of this conflict well upon us, I, like many others in Australia, have watched and absorbed with interest, admiration and occasionally bewilderment and perplexity the abundance of means and formats through which the centenary has and is being commemorated and analysed. There has been no shortage of TV documentaries and dramas; exhibitions and information sessions; services and events; academic monographs and books for kids; each endeavouring to frame a new perspective and to make sense of the First World War, its outcomes and what, if anything, it means to us today - some with greater success and clarity than others. 

Old trench, French battlefield, Evelyn Chapman, 1919. © Estate of the artist.
The Art Gallery of NSW has thrown its hat into the ring with a restrained and yet compelling exhibition of Australian war art entitled, Mad through the darkness: Australian artists and the Great War. On display are works from the Gallery's collection featuring artists such as Will Dyson, George Lambert, Arthur Streeton, Sidney Nolan, Roy de Maistre, and the little-known (although she should be) Evelyn Chapman who was 'the first female Australian artist to visit Europe's First World War battlefields.' Curator, Andrew Yip, conceded that the Art Gallery does not have a great history of commemorating war. In fact, many of the Dyson prints have not been on public display since 1942!

To coincide with this exhibition, the Art Gallery of NSW assembled a group of Australian and Turkish academics for the Gallipoli Gelibolu Symposium with the aim to 'explore the impact of that event on Australian and Turkish art, architecture and material culture and to critically assess the role of visual culture in mediating the conflict's significance within both polities.' It was my very great honour to attend this significant, innovative and inspiring event at the AGNSW on Friday 22 May 2015 at which nine knowledgeable and passionate speakers presented their fascinating and stimulating papers. I would be happy to share the notes I collated from the symposium with anyone interested. But in brief the speakers were as follows:

  • Andrew Yip (Art Gallery of NSW and the University of NSW) defined 'Anzac' as the avatar of Australian national identity for the past one hundred years and 'Gallipoli' as the point of departure for Australia's contribution to warfare. He examined the recent efforts to challenge and diversify the masculine record of war and queried whether these were corrections or re-enfranchisements. Yip then looked at ways we can re-examine the representation of the Gallipoli story during this centenary period.
  • Gizem Tongo (Oxford University) is a Turkish academic who looked at the histiography of the First World War from her homeland's perspective and then compared and contrasted the manner in which both Turkey and Australia have presented the story of Gallipoli through art. Australia has embraced the romantic image of the bushman/digger and so too has Turkey welcomed the brave peasant fighting for his homeland as the nationalist ideal. In both cases the Gallipoli story is intrinsically linked with the legend of the respective 'births of a nation'.
  • Esra Akcan (Cornell University), also from Turkey, spoke of the significance of memorials in society and questioned whether they are complicit with war memories or counter-memories and the constant return to the themes of perpetual war and perpetual peace. Akcan identified the shift from triumphalist to apologetic memorials following the genocide of Jews during World War II and the return to the triumphal in the wake of 9/11 (see Libeskind's 'Freedom Tower' in New York).
    Australian artillery in action, Gallipoli, A.A. Evans
  • Helen Ennis (Australian National University) and Shaune Lakin (National Gallery of Australia) each presented papers on the importance of photography during the First World War. Ennis looked at the development of both aerial and snapshot photography during this period, whilst Lakin examined the mythological and allegorical connotations of A.A. Evans's famous photograph of the Australian artillery in action at Gallipoli and its role in immortalising the idea of the digger as the image of physical perfection and ingenuity.
  • Ryan Johnson (Australian War Memorial) and Anne Brennan (Australian National University) examined the changing interpretations and functions of specific items within the collections at the Australian War Memorial in Canberra. With Wallace Anderson's sculpture, 'Evacuation' as his subject (and one which received a strong critical response in both the Turkish and Australian media recently) Johnson queried how a collection can translate from the material to the online once removed from its physical context. Brennan reflected on the removal from the upgraded First World War Galleries of the large relief maps of the Gallipoli Peninsula and how this may affect our understanding of the terrain.
    Rayner Hoff's Sacrifice, Anzac Memorial. Author's image.
  • Brad Manera (Anzac Memorial, Hyde Park, Sydney) stated that Australian war art, notably Lambert's paintings of the landing and the Battle of the Nek, have informed our historic views of Gallipoli. How will the custodians of the Anzac Memorial inform future generations' understanding of the Australian wartime experience? Manera believes in making connections through the personal stories, documents and ephemera of individual soldiers. Without doubt the highlight of the conference for me was the opportunity to hold a small card written by Lance Corporal Jack Harris to his mother, sending her love and best wishes. It was immensely painful to try to imagine the grief she would have felt when she received it. The card was found on the body of her son after he was killed in the Battle of Lone Pine. He was just 15 years old.
  • The final speaker of the day was Steve Miller (Art Gallery of NSW) who enlightened us on the life and work of Ballarat-born sculptress, Dora Ohlfsen, who created one of the first iconographic works to commemorate the Anzacs.
As well as awarding a stage for these excellent speakers, the Gallipoli Gelibolu Symposium created the opportunity for audience members to engage with and question those presenting papers. This resulted in a lively, constructive and thought-provoking discussion - which carried on during the lunch which was provided! Being seated between the head of art at the Australian War Memorial and the senior historian of the Anzac Memorial was somewhat intimidating (I was internally telling myself to not say anything silly) but was ultimately great fun and a truly rewarding experience.

After lunch we were treated to a tour of the archival room with Steve Miller who had brought out several documents and artworks not included in the main exhibition for us to examine at close hand. Many of these items can be seen through the online exhibition, Hidden War. Later, Andrew Yip led us on an enthusiastic, joyful and candid piece-by-piece exploration of Mad through the darkness which he had obviously enjoyed curating.

The Gallipoli Gelibolu Symposium was one of those very special events I'm sure I will remember and draw from in the years to come. It highlighted the importance of discussion, consideration, collaboration and the need to continually endeavour to re-evaluate and look at things from a fresh perspective. Just brilliant.

Makerspaces

Last week, Dasha, Steph D, Guy and myself attended a Course called "Makers, Craftivists and NSW Public Libraries" at the State Library.

Notes are in Drive but not entirely finished:
Makers, Craftivists and NSW Public Libraries

Once again, the Makerspace Revolution is a hot topic.

In 2014 it was number 7 on ALIA's Trend Library Report, and its popularity has continued to grow.
I thought I would shed some light for those of you who are curious...

Library Success Stories

I went to Library Success Stories at the State Library of NSW.We had talks by the following speakers: 
Pilar Martinez, Deputy Chief Executive Officer Edmonton Public Library, Canada which received Library Journal Library of the Year 2014.
Pilar spoke passionately about staff initiatives,new ways of doing meetings and especially their community efforts. Please see the excellent article below
Edmunton Public Library - LOTY-2014

Library Stars 2014 – Content Winners “Our Words, Our Stories”Debbie Horgan, Greater Taree City Libraries.
A fantastic country library who really believed in this project between the library,TAFE and the local indigenous community.
Library Stars 2014 – Content Runners Up “Lunch-Time Poets”
Kristin Twomey, Tumut Library (via video)
A poetry contest with a twist!! The poems were printed on a paper food bags at the Falling Leaf Festival
Library Stars 2014 – Collaboration Winners “The Coffee Revolution” Margie Kirkness, Greater Taree City Libraries
This library wanted a coffee shop and joined together with a local service provider to have a very successful venture,
Library Stars 2014 – Collaboration Runners Up “Community Connections” Kieran O’Donoghue, Newcastle Regional Library
Newcastle Library
Library Stars 2014 – Capacity Runners Up “Shop-Bound Library Service” Christiane Birkett, Gunnedah Shire Library
Gunnadah library
This small country library saw a need for shopowners to have this service  as they worked the same hours as the library and were often a solo owner.
ALIA Bess Thomas Award 2014 – “ReADtember” Tracie Mauro, Parkes Shire Library
Parkes Library had a writer in residence "Matt Finch"and a whole range of activities including Zombies in Readtember.

Hope you all find inspiration in these stories,I did!!
Thanks Meagan

Lit Up! Literacy forum at State Library

I attended this forum on Wednesday 11th March. It was hosted by the State Library but conceived and organised by the NSW Public Libraries Literacy Working Group. I have been attending their meetings for the last year or so.

I suspect the transcript of the papers will be put up on the web at some point, however I thought I'd share what I got out of the day.

I found some good practical inspiration from the day.

Jan Hagston spoke first. She is a member of the Programme for the International Assessment of Adult Competencies (PIAAC) Literacy Expert Group in Australia. This group is overseen by OECD and the assessment is conducted in 24 countries. Here are some quick and dirty impressions she gave us.
Measurement is conducted in 3 areas :
Problem solving in a technical environment - we (Australians) are quite good at that, above average, our elderly (tech savvy seniors) helped drag us up the scale.
Numeracy - below average - most are at level 2 and below (scale up to 5). 3.6 million between 15 - 75 years, could not answer a visual question asking how full the petrol tank is from a drawing of the gauge. There was a wide range of correct answers.
There was an increase between 2006 and 2012. Of those at this level 49% are males and 59% are women.
Literacy (Reading only..not writing) - not great - Level 2 questions like, on being shown a medicine packet and being asked to  indicate the maximum number of days one can take the medicine, 620,000 between 15 - 75 years could not answer, where there was no other mention of the word 'days' on the packet and the number was a numeral, not written.  Level 4 questions required highlighting a sentence which answered the question, only 2 million of 15 - 75 year olds could answer this.
It was found that the the hardest task to complete correctly, a Level 5 question, was to locate the book in a library catalogue which would best answer the stated need. It required looking at the summaries as the titles did not reflect the subject matter.
Comparatively we are 5th on the list, 2 steps above the average with Japan being at the top. Our percentage on level 2 and below decreased from 45% to 44.3% between 2006 and 2012, but the numbers increased!!
Those in this level tend to be not working or in manual or base administrative positions, over 45, did not complete Year 12, suffer poor health, are NESB and live in Tasmania.

Bruce Caldwell  from the ABS spoke next, about what the above statistics actually tell us.
He stated that 9,000 people were 'pushed' into doing the survey, 55% of which were found to be illiterate. 43% of NSW and 49% of Tasmania got below a level 3, but he said this difference was not statistically significant for this sample size. His point was to say that as with all statistics you can become too focused on the number and not what can be learnt from the trends.The findings do tell us that the lower your skill level the lower your wage and the more likely it is that you will be unemployed. The educational skills of the parents directly relate to the literacy levels of the children. But Australians still rate quite well even if both parents are not tertiary educated. Literacy score was linked to where you live, scores lower the further out of the cities one gets.

Keryl Collard, from Maitland Library spoke about their literacy efforts.
Being literate is to be able to make meaning of information and be able to function well in our complex lives.
Collaboration and co-operation are integral to accessing those who need help. U3A, Hunter Writers Group, Maitland Hospital, University of Newcastle, Friends of Maitland Library and the Early Learning Centres work together to identify and support learners.
Maitland library sees it's mission is to promote literacy in all it's forms. They provide adult literacy tutoring, one on one. Staff are TAFE trained and they have volunteers who are also TAFE trained. They get referrals from TAFE in which they find 50% of people need extra help. They adopt a dual approach with individual goals and common goals. It is something concrete to offer those who are struggling. All staff will be trained, but time and commitment to the process is essential. They started on a scale that was manageable for them. one staff member. A library service needs to connect, be an active stakeholder in community literacy and promote literacy in all it's forms.

Chris Jones from Great Lakes, setting up their Better reading - better communities program
Libraries should be involved in literacy, when one looks at the National statistics and the library trend from book based to people based service. Get strategic, get serious, and get the money. NEED Literacy tutors. create links with TAFE and the Friends of the Library. Create a 2 - 3 page strategy document. Locate volunteers, often from the Literacy Unit in TAFE and train them. The course is 4 hours for 6 weeks.People love volunteering. Network again and again, schools would have taken all the tutors, the problem was finding the adults who needed help, the migrant community is happy to learn and feels no shame in seeking help. Networking opened a can of worms - need resources, staff time and a library literacy team, called Community Literacy meetings and invited those who could use the tutors. It takes effort. Meets regularly, offers literacy volunteers, created promotional material, does reading in nursing homes, a form filling service and an active literacy collection. TIPS: Develop promotional material early to get the word out, keep the tutors engaged and not all people should be tutors, indigenous tutors for indigenous students.

Ruth Coulter, Rebecca Cowie, Maggie Leayr, Suzanne Micallef and Leisa Radford:
Taking the lead project - Literacy Services for Public Libraries Blog
They decided their project would be to create, and maintain the above blog. Which came out of looking for the industry's policy documents and resources themselves and seeing there was a need to make these first steps toward creating adult literacy programs a little easier for libraries, by having aids all in one spot.
The need for literacy services is outlined in these current policy documents.
Living learning libraries 2014 - guideline 13 page 53
Beyond a quality service - guideline 14 page 47
To find stakeholders, think broadly
Find out what is already out there and work with that.

Pamela Davies from Auburn Library - English conversation classes.
2,495 attended in the first quarter of 2015
For kids - homework help, reading buddies volunteers, and Auburn Youth Centre activities
Digital Literacy - NBN funding and they have employed TAFE teachers to train volunteer tutors, and they run Tech Savvy Seniors courses funded by State Government and Telstra.
Adult Literacy - 31, two hour conversation classes per week. Volunteers run it, there is no curriculum, no registration no assessment. Mission Australia gives them heaps of support. Modelled around reading/writing and participation in the community. There is a need to support the tutors, have a meeting each term and buy resources.Tutors need staff intensively when they begin. They must have done either the TAFE course or the Mission Australia course.

Go DiGi - National Digital Literacy Project had a stall at the bookfair/lunch in the afternoon