Frustration for our customers, unneccessary work creation

6 comments
Scenario
Customer in a hurry, prefers books put aside for them as they dash through on way home from work.
3 books on ADD showing available at Sutherland Library, reserved online.
Arrives to collect books but informed they are not yet available. All three are showing"in transit".
Goes home and looks up catalogue to see that all three are still showing available at Sutherland.
Rings library and arranges for the Sutherland books to be put aside while they drive back to the library.
The reserves had all been filled by branches. Three books will now be transported by van to Sutherland, checked in, and sent back by van to the owning branches, where they will be checked in and reshelved.
Waste of staff time, unneccessary carting of goods by drivers, waste of customer's time, how can we improve this service?

6 comments :

Anonymous said...

My initial (simplistic) thought is that staff member informing patron that books not available suggests patron enquires at RA about possible Sutherland copies (or extend SU circulation desk service to do this search)

Anonymous said...

This post was hilarious... I knew it was a joke when I saw that the customer was in a hurry and wanted books on ADD (ha ha).

Point 1 - if customer wasn't in a hurry they would have read the message which comes up when you place a hold which says:' you will be notified when this title is available by SMS or mail' and that may have made them think to ring and check on availability before 'rushing' to the library.

Point 2 - if customer wasn't in a hurry when they came to the library and was informed the items were not yet available, they could have asked staff for further help and had the problem solved immediately instead of going home OR they could have accessed their record via the IPAC in the library themselves to find the items were in transit and then asked staff for help.

Point 3 - when customer finally slows down and asks for help they have the problem solved by library staff whose job it is to assist customers to use a complex system.

This person probably goes online to see if a shop has something on special in stock then rushes out to get it only to find they've sold out, when a simple phone call would have saved them the bother. I imagine this person's life is probably full of frustrations but most of it would be of their own making. Perhaps the books on ADD will recommend some form of medication.

The way Horizon's reservation system works hasn't changed but some people's expectations have. For some reason some people think that by accessing the internet things are done instantly at the other end. However, I would say that the majority of our customers are very impressed with the speedy and efficient request system we have in place and realise that it is in their interest to find out how to use it to their best advantage.

plugger said...

No joke was intended.
An initial discussion with Angus led me to believe that it may have been possible to tweak our Reserves system for the benefit of both customers and our own staff work practices if such a step was authorised.
Angus has kindly investigated all options and shared the reasons why it is not possible for the nominated pickup location to receive first dibs with the PULL LIST.
Here's hoping our new LMS will be more flexible.
Dianne

Jacinta said...

Customers will be customers and we cannot change that. What we can change is what we do, about what they see as deficiencies in our service. We need to cater to our clients no matter what their level of understanding about our services.

Our job as library staff is to make our customers experience of the library as productive as possible so that they are willing to recommend us and return themselves.

It is our job as library staff to be constantly on the look out for efficencies that benefit both us and the customers and lead to them having a positive library experience.

After this recent example highlighting an issue involving the Pull List, since being called to attention, has been discussed with our systems people and the upshot is that unfortunately it cannot be tweaked to put an item on the Pull List of the branch chosen for Pickup (if they have the item on the shelf) Hopefully this will be a feature of our new LMS.

This blog is an excellent way for staff to draw attention to inefficiencies in our systems and to get all staff thinking about how they can be remedied. Many minds working on a problem can lead to creative ways of adjusting our processes to help everyone.

Some of the suggestions which have come out of the discussion of this particular incident have been - what we want our new LMS to be able to do - would it be useful for staff on the entry desk to be allowed to go one step further , and see if there is a copy available at Suth for them to take, instead of those held up in transit? - do away with two desks, create one where those who work on it can take these kind of incidents to their conclusion so the customer is not sent on, and customers can have all their needs met by one staff member.

This is a true approach to customer service, all staff handling all enquiries -- as happens at the branches. Hopefully when we next get remodelling money!

Please keep highlighting areas where we can do better and seek your colleagues ideas on what could help the situation.

Martin Boyce said...

I don't think it is unreasonable for our users to expect that if they check our catalogue online and a book is showing avialable that they can reserve it and come in to collect it.

The fact that our systems and processes didn't satisfy that expectation in this case is a good reason to examine those processes. There are valid reasons why our system is set up the way it is but I think it's good to examine these things to see if they can be improved.

I'm more concerned that Sue and Alison suggest that the customer should have known better or done things differently. As library workers we should all bear in mind that library users find libraries at times intimidating and that they tend not to ask for assistance or read signs. In particular their suggestion that when customer finally slows down and asks for help they have the problem solved by library staff...

It seems that in this case the customer did indeed come to the desk and ask about their holds and yet they still left the library without them while the books were sitting on the shelf.

We have procedures that are supposed to intercept and solve problems like these. We are human and people make mistakes so there is always a chance that our procedures will fail. I don't think that necessarily means that the procedure needs to be changed.

I don't know how the exchange between customer and staff member went in this particular case and so I don't wish to comment on it, however, we failed this customer and I don't think it was their fault.

sue wylie said...

I also find this 'Scenario' very frustrating.
My frustration is that this scenario is based on what 'may' have happened with comments such as 'it seems that in this case...'I don't know how the exchange between customer and staff member went...'
Having worked with the public for many years I have learnt unfortunately, that they cannot always be believed. This is why we continually tell staff to include messages on the customer's cards(if there is an issue)as so often they come back to us claiming something completely different to what actually happened.
Re. 'I don't think it is unreasonable for our users to expect that if they check our catalogue online and a book is showing available that they can reserve it and come in to collect it'
I thought our procedure when we reserve an item for a customer which is showing available, was for them not to assume the item would be here for collection but to ring to check if they were making a special trip here for something that is 'showing available'.
There are 3 items on the 'pull list' tonight which I am unable to find. It may be 'reasonable' for these customers to expect that they can come in to collect these items (as they are showing available) but in reality we cannot guarantee 100% that they will be here.
Sue Wylie