Mosman Library vs That Search Engine

3 comments
Mosman has a great promotion going pitting their reference librarian (using only their electronic resources) against their Internet and IT services librarian (using only Google and freely available web resources) in an epic battle!

Each day they answer a new question and then the public decides who's answer is better.

check it out at: Mosman Library vs That Search Engine

3 comments :

Jacinta said...

This is a very cool idea. The first question the Ref Librarian won hands down, no question.
Not sure if there is a standout winner of the second, they both get the 2 articles quickly. If I had to be critical of anything, the IT guy got one of his articles from an 'online journal', not a REAL one! :)
But I'm sure this will start to become the norm....

Jacinta said...

Actually looked again, the Ref Librarian wins the 2nd too. The IT guy just got a book review from the 'not real' journal. A book review is a not real article!

Triantiwontigongolope said...

I thought this was a great idea. There are so many Patrons that will only use Google with no idea that the information they seek can so easily be found in the subscribed databases or web resources. While the search strategy of both sides made a big difference to their answers I thought this was a really creative way to introduce digital resources and show the community how to use them.

Is there any chance of doing something similar here?

I still can't work out how Ken got so many votes in round 1 however, when he didn't really answer the question.

Karen B.