Future Libaries Without Books?

2 comments
What follows is a response from a staff member to this thought-provoking article, The future of libraries, with or without books, about how some libraries see their future in a world where the information landscape is changing rapidly...
Noooooooo. Never. Please!!! That is not sharing information. That is simply changing a Library to a cinema / video / Twitter et al. ie the quick and easy gratification. That is not promoting or encouraging imagination or the solving of problems through research ie involving the brain. In the future someone will come up with the idea..let's have books / 'they used to have them once' / they give solitude.
There may have been an element of 'tongue in cheek' about this comment but I think the sentiment is quite clear. It may even be unfair to write such a considered response to what was undoubtedly an off the cuff reaction to the article. But I'm not trying to direct my response to any individual. I would, however, like to put forward my views on why I think the changes described in the article are actually a positive thing for Libraries and our communities.

Firstly, let me say that I think that it will be a long time before books are not central to the existence of (at least public) libraries. 'Books' are the library brand. Ask any member of the public what they associate with libraries and I'm very confident the overwhelming response will be books.

But the information landscape has changed to such a degree already that libraries are not the first choice of most people who are seeking 'information'. I'll give you a guess at what is...
(that's right, Google)

Our own recent Enquiry Completion Rate (ECR) survey showed that 61% of all enquiries to the library were for customer service rather than information. I wonder how many of the 39% of information enquiries were people asking if we had a particular book? - The type of enquiry that does not require any particularly professional skills from the librarian.

So can libraries exist as a place reserved for the quiet contemplation of books into the future? Maybe for a while albeit with a distinctly different staff structure. Armed with the data from the ECR why would any funding body hire so many professionally skilled library workers in an environment where the work that required those specific skills was such a small part of what actually goes on? (especially in light of the articles brian pointed us toward) Is it really sustainable? What would Councillors 50 years in the future think about pouring money into a place that stores books when every book is available immediately online?

However, I actually think library story is about much more than just a place for quiet contemplation of books. It is about encouraging imagination or the solving of problems through research. But that just isn't happening in libraries today. If we want to be involved in that way in people's lives then we better start providing spaces where that can happen in libraries and start interacting in the spaces where that is already happening - online! The tools for rapid group self organisation and online conversations already exist and are being used. Libraries can ignore them but the conversation will go on, with or without libraries.

That doesn't mean that libraries should be jumping in to all the programs described in the article - technology spaces, gaming tournaments and social networks. I do think libraries need to explore how they will remain relevant to their communities into the future with all sorts of new ideas. However, new ideas and programs must be accompanied by evaluation, and a willingness to drop them if they they don't prove their worth. I don't think anyone knows what libraries will be like in 20 years time. Introducing new services and programs is about creating a transparent, user-driven library service that adds value to the community.

I believe the prospect of not changing what a library does is far more frightening than any impacts associated with exploring these changes now. The train is leaving the station, get on board...

2 comments :

Anonymous said...

The future may be closer than you think. The Cushing Academy in Ashburnham, Massachusetts has already disposed of their collection of 20,000 books and gone totally digital. Have a look at what they've done and the reaction from the public, librarians and students. It certainly has created a stir and generated hundreds of comments.

Karen B. said...

As a person with a 'strange, emotional attachment' to books, I really can't see them disappearing anytime soon (they smell too good), but I do think that change is inevitable and therefore adaptation is inevitable.

One point Martin mentioned was that Google is now the first choice for information seekers. Rather than oppose this, Libraries may need to play a role in helping users find the right information and evaluate it properly (something most users fail to do). In order to do this, Libraries need to develop a web presence.
Libraries can use collaborative spaces to create this web presence while encouraging creativity, information sharing and feedback in the community.

I don't however, believe that any number of games and movies could replace the value of literature. Everything has it's own purpose and books play a huge role in the community (just watch the storytime and rhymetime kids to see how). I think they should continue to play a major role in Libraries - whether it be in print or digital form.

As an added point, discarding all print resources at once is a ridiculous idea. While use of digital formats is increasing it is still very new and books are still well loved. If there's any change in the proportion of books and digital media in Libraries it should be gradual. That's just common sense.