ALIA Information Online 2021- Beyond Fake news
Beyond Fake news: are we suffering from an information disorder?
Hello there people out in blogland, I am here today to talk to you about an interesting panel session that was part of the recent ALIA information online 2021 virtual conference. The session was about “fake news” and misinformation, something which has been in the spotlight in the past twelve months. The panellists for this session were Dr Timothy Graham, Professor Colin Klein, and Tom Sear.
To start with, one of the panellists defined a few of the key terms that are used in this field.
- Mal-information- genuine information which is spread in a way to cause harm or damage.
- Mis-information- false information spread unwittingly.
- Dis-information- information spread with the intent to deceive.
Here are some of the key points covered by the panellists:-
- Dis-information spread from domestic sources (for example, politicians) can have a very big impact on information disorder. Take the aftermath of the U.S. election as an example.
- People are tied into a system (the Internet) that is highly turbulent & you have a paradox where the U.S. President is in the White House using Twitter to influence.
- There is an assumption that conspiracy theorists have a monological belief system (ie. belief in one Conspiracy Theory predicts belief in more Conspiracy Theories, providing the foundation of generalised conspiratorial perspective), that everything connects to everything else, but research on Reddit suggests more of a gradient depending on the issue- for example, Qanon, may have a monological belief system but this differs from that of anti-vaxers. Another assumption is that conspiracy theorists assertions are sincere expressions of belief- sometimes it’s true but people may just be questioning, or may just have concerns as to what is going on.
- A saying was mentioned- “a certain type of bar provokes fights” but only a certain type of person will go to that bar- a lot of parts of the Internet are like that.
- When looking at outside influences of mis-information perhaps we should ask “where is the outside in a sovereign state any more”? A lot of countries operate in different “stacks”, for example, there’s an English speaking stack, a European stack, and so on. Foreign powers have placed fake entities in other countries- tactics are changing, people are using espionage techniques.
- Social media has solved the problems of scale & speed with information output but not quality. So what you get is the silver bullet hot-take that comes up in your feed & you can’t help but click that re-tweet button.
- Spreading dis-information can be social- people can get social validation from doing it (more so during a pandemic). After all, the Internet is optimised for people with similar interests to get in touch with each other and share with each other.
- We don’t have much in the way of benchmarks- were there lots of people spreading dis-information in the 60’s and 70’s?
- Unfortunately there is a real human cost to information disorder (look at the U.S. capitol riot), it’s not just consigned to the online world.
- To combat the spread of conspiracy theories we should work towards restoring people’s trust in the government & government institutions- a lot of real conspiracies have been uncovered by institutions doing due diligence.
- Perhaps we need to put spotlights on the platforms & algorithms that dictate what you see on the Internet- they aren’t just ad companies, they are curators, editors. Now might be a good opportunity to enact legislation & enforceable codes of conduct that let law makers “inside the black box”.
If you have any thoughts on the issue of fake news please add them in your comments below!
Michael
Subscribe to:
Post Comments
(
Atom
)

No comments :
Post a Comment