Quiet in the library?

3 comments
There have been a few interesting comments in the media recently about libraries and the need for quiet. Leslie Cannold wrote an article in The Age in February bemoaning the lack of quiet in the reading room at the State Library of Victoria and the Librarians' inability to enforce quiet, ''It's not like it was in the old days, love,'' an old codger told me (the "old codger" was a librarian). The article generated 53 comments - most of them seeming to agree with the writer.

Another essay has appeared in response to Cannold's article by Ian McShane (a research fellow at the Institute for Social Research, Swinburne University of Technology). He suggests "Rather than conduct a debate over decibel levels, behaviour in public libraries might better be analysed in terms of civility and public spiritedness."

What do you think? Should we insist on quiet in appropriate areas? Is it a lost cause because of a lack of consideration for fellow students and researchers? Will we lose our younger customers if we rigidly enforce a rule of quiet?

3 comments :

Karen B. said...

I like the setup we have now i.e. the quiet reference study area upstairs and the community space downstairs.

I know that 'back in the day Libraries were quiet places' but from what I've been told from some of the older Patrons back in the day there weren't as many people coming into the Library. The Library was a place for books only. Now there are all sorts of community outreach programs and events. I think the noise in the Library is a sign of changing times more than anything else.

In saying that, I think it is still important to enforce the 'quiet rule' in silent study areas as much as possible because it's true that there are not many places where you can study without background noise.

Max said...

Some public libraries play music throughout the "non quiet" areas!
But if you are going to provide a quiet study area then users have a right to expect just that - a sanctuary where you can study in peace.
As I almost qualify for membership of the Grumpy Old Men club, I feel that in public places people have less and less respect or concern for others. Try going to the cinema without having to put up with idiots making phone calls or texting during the film.
Libraries dont need silence - but it would be nice if everyone showed some respect to others.

Anonymous said...

Looks like Leslie Cannold has some support for her push to make libraries a quiet place once again. Check out her blog.